In my last post, I shared a video outlining the technique for providing an erector spinae plane block (ESPB). Today, I’ll review the most recent analysis of this procedure’s efficacy and safety.

As outlined previously, the ESPB targets the plane between the fascial layers of the thorax, providing analgesia in patients with rib fractures. The technique for use in trauma is relatively new, was first described in 2016, and studies on its effectiveness are finally beginning to accumulate. The most recent and comprehensive was recently published in the Clinical Journal of Pain by a group from Taiwan.

The authors performed a comprehensive search of papers published through 2025. They included only prospective studies comparing pain relief from fascial plane blocks (both ESPB and serratus anterior plane block (SAPB))  with epidural analgesia or no block. They identified only nine papers that included 600 patients, but only 5 used ESPB.

Here are the factoids:

• Overall, fascial plane blocks in general (both SAPB and ESPB) significantly improved subjective pain scores during the first six hours, but were not after that for patients not receiving an epidural
• When looking at SAPB alone, pain scores were improved during the first 24 hours; with ESPB alone, they were only improved during the first 6 hours.
• Both types of plane blocks achieved pain scores similar to epidural analgesia
• Both blocks decreased in-hospital opioid use, but this was not statistically significant
• Hypotension occurred significantly less with fascial plane blocks compared to epidural analgesia
• There was no difference in hospital length of stay with plane blocks compared to standard treatment

Bottom line: What does it all mean? First, there is still too little data to distinguish nuances in outcomes when comparing ESPBs and SAPBs. However, it appears that plane blocks result in less hypotension and so are a bit safer. However, subjective pain scores are only improved during the first 6 hours with ESPB. This suggests that there may be a significant placebo effect for this invasive procedure. Opioid use is the same.

With the exception of the first six hours, ESPB doesn’t look that exciting. It requires special equipment (ultrasound) and a trained provider to perform. It works as well as an epidural, which makes it more useful in patients with contraindications to this modality.

My take is that this may be a promising technique, but it’s still a bit too early to tell. This “large” series included only 600 patients, and fewer than half had the ESPB. So keep studying this procedure to see if it makes sense in the future.

Reference:  Efficacy and Safety of Serratus Anterior Plane Block and Erector Spinae Plane Block for Rib Fracture Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. The Clinical Journal of Pain 42(2):e1334, February 2026. | DOI: 10.1097/AJP.0000000000001334